To Top

Can the Queen really retake America?

The race to become the 45th president of the United States is getting increasingly intense for everyone involved. Controversy, personal tirades and an endless chain of remarkable revelations sent the race into a new level of ferocity.

The election has split the whole nation into two camps. The two rivals, Democrats’ candidate Hillary Clinton and Republicans’ nominee Donald Trump, have repeatedly taken aim at each other, leaving a third group of the electorate feeling disenchanted with much of the language used on either side of the contest.

Frustration has led many Americans to go a bit too far in expressing their discontent. In the midst of the fierce competition, voices emerged to call on Her Majesty the Queen to take back control of the American Colonies that her ancestors ruled. Amusing as they might sound, these calls were not meant as a joke.

While there have in the past been such colourful, and funny at times, suggestions, the fact is that the United States has been an independent country for 240 years. America adopted the Declaration of Independence in 1776, ending 442 days of conflict and 169 years of English, Scottish and, later, British control over its territories, where 85 percent of the white population was of British descent.

Although a reluctant King George III did recognise the Colonies as ‘’free, sovereign and independent states,’’ this concession did not come until 1783 through the Treaty of Paris. The Hanoverian monarch always believed that American independence was a ‘’desperate conspiracy’’ to separate British people in the Colonies from their mother country.

Ever since the British Empire finally lost its 13 Colonies, there have been no serious attempts to retake New England, even during the immediate turbulence that followed the independence. This, according to Spencer Jones, a Historian and Senior Lecturer in War Studies at University of Wolverhampton, was largely due to financial and strategic reasons.

‘’The creation of the United States was followed in 1789 by the French Revolution,’’ Dr Jones told the Royal Central.

‘’Although the loss of America’s closest ally left the United States vulnerable and seemed to provide an opportunity for reclaiming the colonies, there was no appetite for such an adventure in London.

‘’This was due to the severe financial costs of the first War of Independence and the looming threat of Revolutionary France just across the Channel. The prospect of mounting a major expedition to America when France was threatening invasion of Britain was unrealistic.

‘’So… was a reconquest of America and a refutation of the Declaration of Independence ever likely? I am afraid not and any scenario where this occurred must be considered most improbable.’’

The answer to this debate could not be clearer when a reply letter was sent out by Buckingham Palace to one disillusioned American citizen who wrote to the Queen imploring her to take back the Colonies that Great Britain once dominated.

A Buckingham Palace official wrote, “I have been asked to write in response to your recent letter to The Queen in which you express your views about the American government.

“Whilst your views have been noted, you will appreciate, I am sure, that there can be no question of The Queen intervening in the affairs of another Sovereign state.”

So, unlike 15 countries in the Commonwealth realm, such as Canada and Australia, the United States does not have any association with the British Crown, which Her Majesty heads. Although only two monarchs –the Queen herself and her father King George VI- ever set foot in the US in nearly three centuries, there is nothing to suggest that our monarchy intends to alter the strong Anglo-American relationship that currently exists between the two countries.

  • luigi pasquali

    It’s really not worth talking about, but it’s so funny. For one, the Queen doesn’t want to, and can’t do it. Two: no American (not one) wants her to control America if she could. Number three: It’s just a joke, so let’s all have a jolly good laugh.

    • Ross Whitford

      There are actually quite a few American Monarchists who would prefer living under the Queen to the current political system. But I do agree this article wasn’t at all worth writing.

      • Gail

        Agree totally!

  • tired American

    but then of course are the truly exceptional thinkers who believe that all the attorneys in the US, because they have “esquire” after their names, are secretly pledged to the Queen of England in a plot to take over the country. You can’t make it up, people.

  • Anthony Russ

    I think being part of the realm is good, the american people back them made laws and everything and putting a crime for capital crimes, courts, God let him, i don’t know what the problem is frankly

  • Monty Pitts

    Who in the world would suggest this? Someone would have to be awfully mad at Her Majesty to even suggest she might want the Americans back!

  • Bernhardt Le Mechant

    The US could do worse….. and probably will

  • jovan66102

    Whilst I am a committed monarchist, and the sworn subject of Her Majesty the Queen of Canada, living in the States, I do have to laugh at this. Most Americans today probably have no idea that HM’s ancestors ruled the Eastern Seaboard prior to 1783. In fact, a recent survey showed that a sizable minority of Americans thought the States achieved their independence from FRANCE!

    Even if it were feasible, I would only support HM’s claim to former British territory, and if it came to pass, I would support a claim by King Felipe of Spain to the former Spanish territory, and of Monseigneur le duc d’Anjou to the former French territory. There might be a disagreement, however, over the States that make up the old Louisiana Purchase, including Iowa, where I now live. Through pre-US purchase of the land it switched between France and Spain and there were conflicting claims as to which country ‘discovered’ it.

    • DPJ

      You’re right; thanks to our wonderful education system here in America, most young people don’t even know that we had a Revolution, a War of 1812 or even a Civil War. BUT, they do know who is marrying who in Hollywood.

      • Francisco L.

        Everyone knows that there was the Revolution and the Civil War because it’s forced into everyone’s head all the time. The War of 1812 on the other hand… There’s a reason why it’s called “The Forgotten War”.

  • Diane Brown

    I am ready and willing to become a British citizen if this election ends with President Drumpf. My ancestors came from Wales and Scotland and they certainly did not build this country and die in its wars to have a racist fascist hate filled man take the highest office in the land. He is a complete embarassment and our country is imploding. I am 58 and I have never seen such division in my life. He will bring us to the brink and he will take our allies with us. Very scary times. So scary, that I am very serious when I say I am plotting to leave the country. Laugh of you want but many many people are deeply worried and discuss leaving. This is not “celebrity folks” saying they will leave chatter this is mainstream Americans who love their country. I was and remain a Bernie Sanders fan. But America is not ready for progressive socialism as is found in Western Europe. If only they would pick up a book and read they would change their minds.

    Troubling times.

  • Jackie Romagnano

    my ancestors left England on the Mayflower…why, i have no idea…and if George III who was King of England at the time of the Revolutionary War was mentally impaired as we have been led to believe, would he have been sound enough to realize what he was doing by allowing the colonies to go free…for myself personally, i would be exceedingly happy and appreciative to be a subject of her Majesty’s ‘ cause this independence thing is definitely not all it’s cracked up to be as evidenced by the low brow candidate one party has put forward and there lack of a work ethic by not appointing a judge and taking more vacations from work than governing body has a right to…now, her Majesty doesn’t have to take back the whole country…but if she could see her way clear to just reclaiming a few of the original colonies, especially the one i live in, i would be ever so happy

More in Insight

Royal Central is the web's most popular source for the latest news and information on the British Royal Family and the Monarchies of Europe.

Subscribe via Email

To receive the latest Royal Central posts straight to your email inbox, enter your email address below and press subscribe.

Join 31,631 other subscribers.

Copyright © 2017 Royal Central, all rights reserved.